Breakage vs. New Hair


While surfing the  GOC blogs, I would often find naturals who were concerned that they were experiencing breakage because they were finding short hairs. Their posts were filled with consternation because they were practicing healthy hair habits and couldn’t understand why they were experiencing breakage. So, this made me want to write a post for those who suspect breakage when they are doing everything “right.” Guess what? Those short hairs may be new growth!!

via hairfinder 

Q:  How can I tell if the short hair I see is new growing hair or broken hair?

A:  This can often be very difficult to determine, especially if the “short hairs” are in areas where breakage can occur (around the hairline, etc.). Your first task would be to examine the hair closely and look for signs of stress on the hairs – such as split ends, stretching, etc. If there are signs of stress or damage, then breakage is the likely cause. This can be doubly certain in cases where breakage would be expected. For example: an individual wears his/her hair in, say, a tight ponytail and begins to notice short hairs at the forehead and temples.

Breakage becomes less likely when the short hairs are found in places on the scalp that aren’t exposed to significant stress from the styles worn. For example if you generally wear your hair loose and parted in the middle, but notice hairs that “poke up” between the other hairs on the scalp that are NOT along the parting, there is a reasonable chance that the hair is simply “new growth” in follicles that have recently shed their hairs.

This new growth of hair will not be found in great numbers. Since only 10% of the hairs on average are in a resting phase at any given time (the rest being in a growth phase) and the hairs are shed following the resting phase as the new hair pushes the old hair out of the follicle, you would generally only see 10% of the hairs on your head as these short, newly-grown hairs.

In addition to the above, a few things one should think about when trying to diagnose breakage are:

  • Are the ends of the short hairs tapered or blunt? Tapered hairs tend to be new growth whereas blunt and split hairs or hairs with white ends are indicative of breakage.
  • Does the majority of the hair on your sink or in your comb/brush, have “roots” (white bulbs) attached or are many/most strands rootless? Strands with white bulbs are shed hair and not breakage.
  • Do you hear *snap, crackle, pop* when combing or manipulating your hair? If you do, it’s probably breakage and the best thing to do is handle your hair more gently and ensure that it is well lubricated/saturated (with a pre-poo or conditioner – some prefer wet hair and others on dry) before attempting to detangle slowly from ends to roots. I prefer to finger detangle first as I’m able to feel the bad knots and tangles in order to gently ease them out, rather than ripping through them with a comb/brush.
  • Do you have a lot of split ends and/or SSKs? Both of these can cause breakage as the splits and knots can/will snag on adjacent hairs and cause additional damage. I’m a fan of the S&D method to keep knots and splits to a minimum.
  • Do you use heat often and/or forgo heat protection? Do you re-apply heat to “dirty” hair? Try reducing or eliminating direct heat. Opt for roller sets and silk wraps rather than a flat iron if you want straight hair and always use a heat protectant. Keep the passes over your hair to a minimum (1 0r 2) if you must use a flat iron or curling iron. Only “press” freshly clean and 100% dry hair.
  • Do you use hair tools with metal parts or materials that can snag or tear? Do you protect your hair at night? Opt for barrettes, clips and hair elastics without metal parts, such as Goody Comfort Flex Barrettes, Ouchless ponytail holders, banana clips and satin scrunchies. Sleep on a satin pillowcase and/or wear a satin scarf or bonnet.
  • Is your hair well moisturized or is it often dry and brittle to the touch? If so, are you moisturizing with a water based styler or leave-in and sealing with an oil or butter? Have you tried weekly deep conditioning treatments with a moisturizing DC? (There is an ongoing debate on the hair boards about the effectiveness of DCs and DCs with heat, but I am a believer. I believe the only way for you to know if they will make a difference for you is to give them a try.)  Are you overdoing protein DCs and/or not using a moisturizing DC as a “protein chaser?”
  • How do you style your hair? Too much tension on the hair, especially fine and fragile curly hair, can cause damage. I personally opt for low manipulation and protective styles that I can wear for 2-5 days. I’ve also grown MBL hair with WnGs, so it is possible. However, everyone’s hair responds differently and to different things. The key is finding what works the best for you.

That being said, in 2010 I experienced two things. One, I had breakage along my center part in the Winter of 2010, which I suspect was caused by using a protein-based gel (my hair and protein don’t get along well). In addition, my hair began shedding like crazy and I think that was caused by using amla in my henna, which my scalp did not like. I stopped using that protein gel last Spring and it appears that I have finally resolved my excessive shedding problem by discontinuing use of amla and avoiding getting conditioner on my scalp. As I don’t see a lot of breakage, rarely hear a *snap, crackle and/or pop* and it appears that the end of my short hairs are tapered, I believe my hair is in the recovery phase where the hairs that broke and shed are regrowing.  Although I’m certain the short hairs represent more than 10% of  my hair, knowing that I’m taking care of my hair as well as I can and am employing a well-founded regimen and techniques, I don’t worry about it. If  you think that you are experiencing mechanical damage, then take a closer look at your regimen and/or techniques. However, if your regimen and techniques are on point, breathe a sigh of relief because those shorts hairs are most likely new growth and the result of your healthy hair efforts!!


20 responses »

  1. Hummmmm… I thought tapered ends would signify hair that broke off similar to how split ends look. I’d be glad if my assumption was false. That would mean I have tons of new strands.


    • The info I found indicated that the new hairs are tapered. However, I think you can have breakage with tapered ends, especially if the hair is splitting along the shaft. The key is to look at all of these things in conjunction with each other, in my opinion. If you are not seeing breakage on your comb/brush/sink and you are not putting under strain on your strands, then I think there is a good chance that the hair is new growth.


  2. I’m glad you wrote this post because I have lots of fuzzies and I don’t think they are broken hairs. They do represent more than 10% but i’ve been very careful with my hair and am always looking for hair in the comb, on the sink and on my clothes. I experience very little breakage and very little shedding. The last time I noticed breaking was when I shared how my hair was snapping when I combed it dry. Well, that was the last time I did that!

    By the way, I tried the hairstyle that you and Rece did with the bun. I posted a pic in my fotki. I’m going to post on the GOC blog too.

    It didn’t come out as well for a few reasons:

    1) Hair did not dry at all! I can’t understand how my hair just takes forever to dry. It’s not even long all over.
    2) I had bangs in the front that while they have grown, they don’t reach all the way back to the bun. So I improvised and added a twist and played with the bobby pins 🙂
    3) I tried the goodie spin pins but they make my buns look so small. Can you pretty please redo that part of the video of how you hold and put it in? I tried to twist it tight at the root but then when I let go to wrap the rest around, it got all messy! I gave up and put in a good ouchless with elastic (have to be careful with these. Even though there is no metal, it can still break the hair if it gets tangled)

    OK, that was a long mouthful but you know me LOL. I’m going to redo this style tomorrow for my 1 day cruise in PA 🙂


  3. Yeah, the combing dry is a deadly duo!! Glad you stopped that! LOL! I’ll check out the pics of your updo. As to the bun with the Goody Spin Pins, I’ll try to film that again before the week is over. However, you can’t release the twist at the root. You have to hold that tight with one hand and then loosely wrap/graso the other hair with the ends kind of tucked under to insert the spin pins. And, yes, I agree about the Goody ouchless elastics! That’s why I was so happy to find the spin pins and banana clip. I always have hair wrapped around and ripped out by the elastics. I have minimal to no hair pulled out with the pins and the banana clip. Love ’em!!


    • I sort of rewatched your video again and think my technique is off. I don’t want to cause you any more “work” so let me watch it again while I’m actually doing it lol. unless somebody else wants a re-record?

      i love the banana clip too. I’ve perfected that technique. As for the elastics, i’m REAL careful but every now and then I have at least 1 hair on it. The first time I did it, I had a little ball that my husband had to untangle! He did a good job but I still lost a little piece.


  4. Spin pins made my bun look microscopic too… and if the bun was a good size, it was too loose at the top.

    I’m pretty sure my short hairs are breakage. That line of demarcation follows me everywhere I go. Blah! Lol


  5. That explains the curly that have suddenly started growing in the front of my hair. I suspected they might have been the baby hairs that suddenly decided they wanted to be adult hairs.


  6. Pingback: New Growth or Breakage? ::

  7. Pingback: Breakage vs. New Hair: UPDATE! « hairscapades

  8. Pingback: Do You Have Hair Breakage, or New Growth? | cinagrOrganic

  9. This post describes my hair perfectly. However, my hair is just not cooperating at all and seems to be getting worse as I try. My main focus is to get rid of the short hairs in the front! Also, I have hairs both long and short that are curly at the root and then become straight as it comes down which looks horrible. Please help!


  10. Pingback: Do You Have Hair Breakage, or New Growth? | On The Scene NY

  11. Pingback: 3 Things You Wouldn't Guess Are Causing Damage To Your Hair - MNHE

  12. Pingback: 3 Things You Don't Know Are Damaging Your Hair - MNHE

  13. Is there a glossary where I can catch the acronyms lol? I love the info sis I promise you. This article was a brook in a desert. I just wasn’t able to follow as clearly as I would’ve liked 😊


Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s